Tag Archives: Bagobo
A study on the tribal structure of the Bagobo tribe in comparison with the Barangay structure of Barangay Batasan A study on the tribal structure of the Bagobo tribe in comparison with the Barangay structure of Barangay Batasan Makilala, North CotabatoMakilala, North Cotabato
Community Organization and Participatory Research
This report is the product of the study conducted from May 1991 to May 1992. The study was commissioned by the Canada-Asia Partnership (CAP) program of which Ateneo de Davao University (ADDU) through the Institute of Primary Health Care of the Davao Medical School (IPHC-DMSF) is a partner institution. Two courses were offered in Participatory development: Community Organizing through Participatory Action Research(COPAR) and Enterprise.
The project team consisted of Lourdes Mamaed, a socio- economist, Eleanor May Ursos, an anthropologist sociologist and Ely Acosta, a social worker. The three are faculty members of the Social Sciences and Education Division of the Ateneo de Davao University, Davao City, Philippines. They were assisted by the project officers of the two pilot areas: Rose Ontal of IPHC-DMSF for Bagobo Village, Calinan, Davao City and Melba Laguna of the Social Involvement and Coordinating Office (SICO) and Gloria Penera of the Institute of Small Farm Industries GSFl) for Purok Glivbext. SICO and ISFl are extension offices of the ADDU.
The team members were course planners of the CAP program. Each one of them was a module coordinator of the COPAR course which promoted community organizing with the integration of participatory action research. The mission of the study, was to identify two pilot areas: one to be organized and the other an organized community. The objectives were to:
1. experience the complete cycle of the COPAR
2. document the experience in both areas
3. assist the community in the formulation of the comprehensive plan for implementation
4. prepare and train communities to become a trainor community on COPAR
Purok Glivbext of Obrero, Davao City was the area to be organized. It was chosen on the basis of the following:
1. there was an existing project initiated by the social work department of the ADDU
2. the presence of potential leaders to be tapped for community organizing
3. no agency has entered the place for service implementation
4. The place, as a squatter area, has various problems like: presence of out-of-school youth, poor drainage and sanitation and malnutrition among others.
Bagobo Village was chosen as the second pilot area. It was a community that was organized by the IPHC through Integrated Local Development (CHILD) program. The CHILD was phased out and so the COPAR was introduced to promote better participation and more involvement among the members.
The team made an average of six visits per month to the area excluding the number of days spent for trainings. Visits were done at anytime of any day while meetings and trainings were conducted only on weekends or during the evening of weekdays.
In terms of methodology, four approaches were utilized to attain the objectives of the study. These included working with communities, process documentation, participant observation and key informant interviews.
The study team went to the area to organize and train leaders to prepare them for any undertakings that they would initiate. They followed the COPAR process step by step. Project officers of both areas came in for project implementation.
The members of the core group and local research team from both communities came and had a two-day training together at the Ateneo de Davao University. Since each community had its own problems to research on, the second training on data processing and analysis was conducted separately. The rest of the trainings were conducted in their respective communities and these were staggered. An input was usually given first after which the participants were sent to the field for actual workshop. They were asked to come back the next scheduled date to S5mthesize the workshop output.
After having undergone the complete cycle of the COPAR process the team documented their experiences.
The study team observed other activities initiated by the local community organizers. The focus of observation was the participation and active involvement of the members.
Persons who were knowledgeable about any of the two areas were interviewed. The necessity of such was to establish an organizing profile. Interview guides were designed to gather the following information: who were the leaders; how were they chosen: who identified the problems; what projects have been implemented; and how do they evaluate.
The basic tenet of COPAR is that knowledge leads to power. Equipped with enough knowledge, acquired skills and the proper attitudes, people’s awareness is increased and better participation in development projects can be expected. Power in this context is conceptualized thus:
— people can organize their own community
— people can identify and prioritize their own problems
— people can do their own research and analyze social realities in their own communities
— people can plan and take action on the problems identified
— people can monitor and evaluate their projects
— people have the capacity to evaluate new knowledge from their experiences contributing further to the understanding of people’s behavior in development
This is the step whereby the CAP researchers with the help of available baseline data went for a courtesy call to the purok leaders to present the program. This was also an initial meeting with the Glivbext COPAR Experience respondent community to get the people’s commitment to the said program.
The team with the community members defined what is a leader and who can be a leader. Then they identified leaders to compose the core group or local community organizers, the counterpart of the project officers.
The elected leaders were given a training on leadership, planning, facilitating and community organizing. The end result of the training was the formulation of the mission statement and the setting of goals.
The LCO called for a general meeting to re-echo what they had learned from the training they had undergone. Then with the community members they identified problems that really affect them. In the same meeting, they also selected a group of local! researchers to look more into the identified problems.
The elected local researchers were given a training on how to gather, collate and tabulate data; and how to analyze and interpret the gathered data. The result of the research was validated with the community members.
Once the research data was validated, the community again’ elected a team of planners. They were also given training on how; to make plans and prepare project proposals. The training output was presented to the community members for approval.
The members of the implementing team were chosen from the assembly. These, then, were given the orientation on the approved plan. They were expected to come up with the implementing guidelines to be presented to the people.
The monitoring and evaluating team was elected by the people. This team had the responsibility of looking into the flow of the process and its evaluation. The training output of monitoring and evaluating tools was presented to the community for final approval.
Glivbext COPAR Experience
Today, more emphasis is given on the element of people’s participation in the development process of their communities, the serious attention directed to participation by development planners has given way to concept called Community Organizing through Participatory Action Research (COPAR). It is an approach that hopes to promote the formation of local organization by the People themselves, identifying their needs and problems and acting on these whenever possible.
For the past years, a lot of experimentation on the COPAR process were done to translate the concept into reality. A review of actual field experiences of various people participatory programs has revealed however, that there is much to be desired. We cannot deny the difficulties associated in bringing upliftment to the poor considering the magnitude of problems involved hence, the results have been disappointing. Although government and private initiatives have succeeded in at least forming community organizations among the poor communities, these organizations did not become viable and capable of self-determination.
This section presents the field experiences of the researchers in the implementation of COPAR project in a poor urban community, GLIVBEXT. Although the project has been in operation for only one year, the experiences may bring out insights that may be helpful in identifying factors essential in promoting people’s participation and development.
Project Site
Glivbext, a purok in Agdao, is a slum area with about 129 households. It is here where most of the slum dwellers in Davao City live. Most of the households in Glivbext have a large family size. The educational status of the residents is relatively high compared to other poor communities. In spite of this, the families live in abject poverty where the income is way below the poverty threshold.
Many times, the residents experienced demolition threats from private landowners in the area since 93 percent of them did not own the lot where their houses were built. Livelihood programs of government and non-government agencies have been slow in coming to the area. Indeed the community is often described to be “sleeping”. The people in Glivbext have not yet experienced disappointments from failure of development programs. There is thus an openness to take positive attitudes towards change.
The Local Community Organizers (LCO) were given training on May 25-26, 1991 with the LCO members of the BAVILCOI, Calinan, It was a two-day training held at the Ateneo de Davao University. The topics discussed were leadership, planning, facilitating and community organizing. The end result ‘ of the seminar was the definition of their role in the community and the formation of the association called NAGKAHIUSANG KATAWHAN SA PUROK GLIVBEXT, INCORPORATED that has the following objectives:
1. promoting unity in the community
2. assisting in the delivery of services with any agency who may enter the area;
3. encourage better participation of the members in any community effort that may lead to the developrnen4 of the area.
The LCO called for a general assembly after the training to re-echo what they have learned. Then with the community members, they identified some problems that really affect the people. These problems were low income, lack of unity among the residents, land problem, poor drainage and sanitation, malnutrition, and increasing number of out- of- school youth.
To validate the problems identified, a group of local researchers were elected towards the end of the meeting. These local researchers, were given two sets of training. Training I was on data gathering methods namely, focused group discussion, participant observation, process documentation, historical mapping and survey. Since this is but a newly organized community, the local researchers agreed to make a study of the community or community profile with the use of survey. The data gathering involved preparation of the research instrument, pre-testing and the actual interview with all the members of the organization. Training H included editing of forms and construction of tables and graphs, data analysis and reporting and preparation for the research validation and consultation.
After the community validated the problems presented by the survey, they elected a group of planners. The following was the outline of the topics given:
I. What is a plan? Planning?
II. Steps in planning:
1. situational analysis
2. problem identification
3. problem analysis
4. problem prioritization
5. objective setting
III. Importance and some considerations in planning
IV. Project proposal-making
V. Business plan
At the end of the training, they were able to come up with the first draft of the project proposal for an income generating project which will be submitted to ISFI for funding.
After the plans were presented to the people during tit! community assembly for approval, the same people were request’ by the community members to implement the program. And ‘s° they were called for another training, with the following as inputs’
I. People’s organization: its formulation and management
II. Project implementation in the community
III. Other skills depending on the projects planned.
The output of the seminar was the formulation of criteria for (IGP) income generating projects beneficiaries and making of guidelines for the applicants. Again, this was presented W the people for approval.
While the implementing teams were assessing applicants to the IGP, a group of monitors and evaluators were elected during the general assembly. They were given inputs on:
I. What is monitoring/evaluating?
II. Why do we monitor/evaluate?
III; Phases/steps in monitoring/evaluating
A workshop followed whose end result was the formulation of the monitoring and evaluating scheme. The scheme was presented to the members for final comment and for their approval. The NKPGI is a ten month old organization but has achieved many things such as:
1. ten (10) members received capitalization for their income generating projects-like sewing, food vending, sari-sari store, etc.
2. putting up a Project Hope with a center of their own;
3. fund-raising projects through sayawan;
4. conducting social action where they protested the process of terminating local leaders;
5. acting as mediator in resolving personal conflicts;
6. turning over the consumers cooperative to the LCO
The members realized that having the proper attitude and following the policies set were necessary in undertaking successful projects. Regular follow-ups done by the monitoring team were significant in finding solutions of problems encountered by project beneficiaries. Evaluation reports of project follow-ups were discussed during regular meetings of the core group and general membership.
The Bagobo Community (BAVILCOI)
Calinan is a promising district of Davao City. In this district is situated a community whose name has been derived from the owner of the land, a mestizo Bagobo, Jose Lee. It is perhaps through this brief historical background that the community was named Bagobo although the residents in the area are largely migrants and not ethnically of Bagobo origin. Majority are Cebuanos (85%), Boholanos (10%) and Ilongos (5%). Residents are engaged in subsistence farming and contract labor in nearby plantations and pineapple cannery and small-scale business.
The Bagobo community is otherwise known as purok 27 of Calinan district. The area is 27 kilometers from Davao City and can be easily reached (about 40 minutes to 1 hour) by public utility vehicles. The community occupies around two (2) hectares of the land owned by Lee. The village residents are tenants of the land.
The lot rental ranges from P30.00 to 150.00 a month depending on the size the family occupies. There were more or less 102 households with a total population of 675 individuals.
The birth of Bagobo Village Community Organization Incorporated (BAVILCOI) can be traced in the later part of 1989 when the Institute of Primary Health Care of the Davao Medical School Foundation (IPHC-DMSF) entered the area armed with the program on Community Health through Integrated Local Development (CHILD). The program focused on child health the objective of which was to reduce mortality rate of children from 0 – 6 years.
As a child beneficiary, if was here that the community was exposed to the concepts and processes of community organization and development. Education — basic health education, capability building, leadership training, simple bookkeeping, food preservation and other ideas were taught through short term seminars and trainings. The objective was to create an individual willingness and eagerness on the part of the people to try new methods and to develop new patterns of living.
In 1990, the CHILD project was phased out. In a sense, although the Bagobo community showed some degree of capability to go on with their organizational activities and projects, some kind o intervention for sustainability was needed as felt by the people themselves.
The implementation of the COPAR process in Bagobo Village, Calinan started on May, 1991. They were chosen as the organized area for COPAR on the basis that they have been using participatory approaches in the past through the implementation of the CHILD project by the IPHC.
The Ateneo project team with the help of the former project officer of the CHILD visited the place and did some ocular survey purposely for the following reasons:
1. To see and get acquainted with the physical and social conditions of the community
2. To pay a courtesy call and talk to the organization leaders to inform them of the project that the CAP–ADDU project team will undertake
3. To get acquainted with the BAVILCOI leaders and reactivate the former leaders
4. To know of the people’s cultural orientation and beliefs
A membership assembly was soon called by the BAVILCOI officers to explain the CAP program and what is expected of them. This consultation meeting resulted into an acceptance of the program by the membership who further committed themselves to learn and implement the COPAR process.
From the same assembly, ten members were elected to compose the core group, majority of which are also officers of the organization. They were chosen based on the principle of shared leadership and one who has the time, talent and potential and most of all one who will commit himself to the said project. These core group members are otherwise known as. local community organizers, the counterpart of the agency’s project officer. They were given training on leadership skills, communication, facilitation and community organizing together with the Glivbext group. It was conducted in Ateneo last May 25-26, 1991. The output of the training was the formulation of their vision and mission statement and the setting of goals.
After the training, the LCO’s called for another general assembly wherein they re-echoed what they have learned. By using skills acquired from the training and with the collaboration of the members, several problems were identified and were narrowed down to four major concerns:
1. low income
2. lack of water supply in their farm site which consequently will be converted into a residential area
3. lack of road facilities from farm to the center
4. lack of power supply
To validate the problems identified, another group was elected to compose the local researcher. This team was trained under CAP supervision. The first set of training was on data gathering. They.. joined the Glivbext group for the input which was held in
Ateneo, but since their research topic was specific on problems, the second training on data analysis was conducted in the area. The result of this research were reverted to the community for consultation and validation. From these social realities, they identified the problems, prioritized them and saw the need for action. In addition, the local researchers were also able to make a historical map of their organization.
Once the problems presented were properly validated by the community, another group was elected—the planners. The group likewise underwent a training on the concepts and principles of planning. The elected local planners had a workshop on planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation. The low income problem was not tackled by the group anymore because they already have their communal farming. The planning team divided themselves into three sub-teams, each composed of two members. The sub-teams then proceeded to tackle the water supply plan, the road access problem and the electricity problem. Each team came up with a planning scheme on how to solve the problem.
The plans laid down by the planning team were again reported to the general assembly for approval. By the unanimous consensus, the same people were requested to implement the program they devised. Since the organization was already experienced in implementing projects, the group decided to skip the implementing training. Instead the project manager who at the same time was an LCO member, asked the general membership as to what project will they go into first. The members agreed to tackle the road problem before the others.
Finally, a group of monitoring and evaluation teams were elected to follow-up and evaluate the plans. They were given a one-day input on what is monitoring and evaluation, its importance and the steps involved. Then they went into a workshop. As n output, they came up with monitoring and evaluating schem s. This was presented to the community members for approval.
The BAVILCOI today stands as an example of a people’s organization which has undergone the process of growth and achieved a measurable degree of development through participatory action. This is apparent in the members’ sense of worth and belonging, realized through the discovery of their individual capabilities and potentials exercised in unity and cooperation. Now they are being asked to talk as resource persons in the organization of other communities or are asked to give an input on specific topics. The community is fully aware that it s only through participatory process whereby they can achieve their vision of a happy, healthy and progressive community.
Of late, community organizing has come to be accepted as a means for community participation in development activities. Through organizing, communities are made aware of their potential for collective action to improve their lot and are mobilized and trained to realize this potential through the conduct of cooperative endeavors
In the case of the CO-PAR project in Glivbext, the organizing was handled by the CAP team who received training in CO-PAR. As organizers, the team created the opportunities and mechanisms for the community members to participate in various project activities. This participation became the basis for developing and enhancing further the members capability for undertaking research, collective planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of projects.
In the case of Calinan, the team simply gave the training workshop on how to use the process. The organizing effort was handled by the project officers from IPHC and the project manager of the BAVILCOI with the assistance of the board of directors. Finding out the possibilities for participatory research among poor communities needs a longer period of time of working with the people. However, the experience for one year in Glivbext and Bagobo Villages indicated some positive factors and gaps in the undertaking.
1. People in poor communities are keenly interested in studying their own situation particularly in cases pertaining to livelihood and other community problems. By objectifying, measuring and pinpointing their problems they became more aware about their life situation and are more ready to respond to their problems.
2. Local leaders and even ordinary community residents can be effective persons in facilitating community-based research. Research skills can be translated, at their levels, through trainings.
3. In contrast to researches done by outside agencies, participatory research is seen as the community’s own undertaking. Results are immediately given back to the people; interviewers are known by the local residents; the language of local research is ordinarily in the vernacular and the questions raised are then brought to the people in the community for consultation.
4. The data gathered may be more reliable and accurate if only because both the interviewer and respondents know and trust each other.
5. Local researchers have to be given more training and supervision on data processing and analysis, and the making of research reports.
6. There is a danger that the biases of local researches may limit the applicability of their findings and conclusions.
7. Community residents if properly motivated, become active members by volunteering their time, money, effort to achieve their goal.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The COPAR process is applicable at any level of community organizing. Whether the community is already organized or not,, application of COPAR always starts with the identification ofl the leaders or local community organizers who proceeded with they identification the research problem and so on. It is therefore recommended that the COPAR process be repeated in the communities of Glivbext and Bagobo Village for the local leaders’ to really master and value the participatory process. Doing so will really prepare them to become a trainor community of the CAP’ course participants. Specifically, recommendations for the two areas are:
A. Calinan
1. That the IPHC, DMSF, continue assisting the BAVILCOI until such time that they are financially stable.
The organization at present is concentrating on paying back the IPHC the amount loaned to them for the purchasing of the communal farm. Ultimately, this farm will be converted into a housing program. They would need further assistance for the processing of the lot title and for the initial construction of their houses. Some would even need capitalization for an income generating project to augment their income.
2. That value formation sessions be continued for the people to really appreciate two major values: participation and social responsibility. Some members are not active in helping out in the communal farm. They prefer to give money instead of working together with the rest of the members. Some members counted their effort and compared themselves with others. Community development can better be achieved if all the members received proper orientation on the importance of the unification of all efforts and the understanding of the responsibility of each member to give his share for the attainment of the organization’s objectives.
B. Obrero
1. That more trainings/workshops be given to strengthen the organization. At present, the organization is still dependent on the organizers for some activities that they want to undertake.
2. That the ISFI and SICO continue to extend technical and financial assistance to the community. The cooperative has not started yet due to lack of a common orientation and the knowledge how it is to be run. Some members are waiting for their turn to be the recipient of the IGP.
3. That a value formation session be conducted. The members need this for the redirection of their values from personal to societal. At the moment some members are a little bit competitive. The spirit of concern and a sense of responsibility to the group are still lacking.
Along the objective of preparing the people to become a trainor r tn community there is a need to repeat the complete cycle of the process in both pilot communities for the people to value and understand the meaning of PAR.
In Obrero, the whole Process is very clear but the research team has limited experience. Their research work emphasizes so much on the community profile. They should acquire the knowledge and develop skills of studying the problems identified. In the Calinan community, the workers tend to confuse the process because the original group who received training during the CHILD days has the tendency to compare what they learned previously with that of CO-PAR, hence they resist the latter.
The Myths of the Bagobo, Tagakaulo and Mandaya: An Ethnological Analysis
The great historian of religion, Mircea Eliade, said that myth defines itself by its own mode of being. It can only be understood in so far as it reveals something as having really happened, as in an event that took place in primordial times. Primordial time is not the same time as our historical time. In fact, it is timelessness. Mythical stories are usually one in which gods mingle freely with men who also have access to heaven or the abode of gods and divinities.
Mythical stories are always about explanations of mysteries such as how the world was created, or how men and women and the littles insects came to be. As such, myths reflect a people’s understanding of the whole reality of existence, and the individual’s place in it. The two most significant constituents of myths are the universal and the exemplary. Myths do not treat of individual in relation to the total reality, or cosmos. Men’s individual problems are precisely caused by violations or deviations from their assigned roles and to resolve these problems one has to do through the correct or prescribed act of behavior the way it was done “at the beginning”. Many rituals fall in this functional category. The whole catalogue of oral literature of many traditional cultures, e.g. fables, legends. riddles, etc.. serve to remind the individual about the exemplary deed and right behavior, In myth, man is an integral part of creation but not necessarily the most important or distinguished.
Above all these, myth and myth-making have a deeply spiritual and religious dimension. The apprehension of a myth is considered as a very religious experience because it is a revelation of sacred reality. Eliade describes the phenomenon as “the irruption of the sacred into the profane”. That is to say that the human mind cannot of itself come to a realization of the whole cosmological reality. Those who have participated in myth-making were able to do so only because they have actually experiences a hierophany.
For this reason, it is very interesting to study the myths of other people for then one would be able to understand their own particular religious experience and how this experience is contextualized in their culture. The best way to understand a myth is to refer to the culture. The best way to understand a myth is to refer to the culture of those to whom the myth is the perception of total reality or cosmogony. We will now proceed to an ethnological analysis of the myths of the Bagobo, Tagakauolo and Mandaya.
An ethnological analysis has a number of cultural referents. The sociological structure of the myth is held to reflect the structure of the society or community to whom the myth belongs. In this wise, the web of relationship among gods and men would be very similar to, if not the same as those in human society. The motifs or elements would indicate the adaptations made by the local authors. Finally, encoded in the mythical story is the people’s ideology or belief system, the very foundation of the spiritual and religious experience of the people.
Bagobo Mythology
The bagobo believe that Tiguiama, a good god, created all things but other gods have their own specialized participation:
1. Mamale – created the earth
2. Macoreret – created the air
3. Domacolen – created the mountains
4. Macaponguis – created the water
An ancient ideology is encoded in the Bagobo ideology and belief system. The myth of a terrible god who lived in the volcano, and who demands, as well as devours human victims has animated Mt. Apo. This has enabled the Bagobos to structure a relationship and define a code of conduct towards a dominant and therefore significant feature of the environment. The myth of Mandarangan and Darago, husband and wife guardians of Mt. Apo, renders intelligible the practice of human sacrifice among the Bagobos. The myth conveys the Bagobo notion of evil as an inescapable part of reality and how it is dealt with.
The polytheistic belief system allows the worship of other gods. While Mandarangan permits the Bagobos to come to terms with the terrible reality of evil, Eugpamolak Manobo, another divinity, reflects the Bagobo’s appreciation of the good, which notion is equated with nature’s bounty. Pamolak is the word for plant as well as for flower, the harbinger of the fruits of the earth, and the placement of this deity in the Bagobo pantheon pays homage to nature and an agricultural existence.
The most eloquent abstraction of the Bagobo’s ineffable regard for nature’s bounty is found in the story of Tuglay and Tuglibong, the archetypes of the first man and first woman. The couple’s progeny would have all but perished were they not refreshed by a single stalk of sugarcane, a gift from the gods, growing lustily in the midst of a scorched plot of earth.
The memory of a scorching period is distinct in the origin myths, especially in the story of how Tuglibong, the first woman, along with the rest of the mythical figures of old, were said to have lived an intolerable existence because the sky and the sun hung low over the earth. The mythical people, known as mona, had to live in holes and crevices under the earth to protect themselves from the sun’s heat. Moreover, important activities were severely constrained, e.g. pounding rice was a difficult activity since one could hardly move one’s elbow, cramped as it were by a low hanging sky. All these changed when, finally, through Tuglibong’s sustained scolding, the sky, and with it the sun, bolted up to their present position thus ushering in a new epoch whereby the mona lived on the surface of the earth instead of underground. They were able to build houses, the temperature cooled, and nature and the human race were regenerated — the mona who were already old began to have babies!
The god Lumabat and his sister, Mebuyan, goddess of fertility (she is depicted as a woman with breasts all over her body) and guardian of a Bagobo Limbo for dead babies, were children of Tuglay and Tuglibong. The tale of Lumabat is the story of a culture hero who journeyed to the ends of the earth, i.e. the horizon, and after successfully avoiding a number of pitfalls reached the land of the diwata or gods. Lumabat himself became a god when the diwata divested him of his intestines after which he no longer was bothered by hunger. Lumabat’s journey to the sky country was fraught with a number of obstacles; he and his companions passed a region where one could be turned into a stone or a tree if one responded to any of these objects that could talk. This land was conceived as lying beyond the sea, the Gulf of Davao. The sky country itself was thought to be located on the other side of the horizon, the idea of which was construed as a pair of giant jaws which mechanically opened and shut to the peril of those who, like Lumabat, attempted to cross to the other side. Giant jagged teeth and kampilan (swords) fencing by themselves added to the dangers of the traveller.
Mebuyan’s myth was woven differently from that of her brother. Unwilling to go with Lumabat to the sky country, Mebuyan plummeted to the underworld by sitting on the rice mortar which began to spin downward as soon as Mebuyan sat on it. Mebuyan soon founded a kingdom of her own, Banwa Mebuyan, a place where she fed babies until they were weaned from her many breasts. She also personified death; by shaking a lemon tree people died according to the kind of leaves that fell from the tree. If old and yellowed leaves fell, old people would die, but if the leaves were green and newlygrown, young people would perish from this earth.
Human sacrifice, which the Bagobos practiced until the turn of the present century, was an offering to Mandarangan and Darago as well as to Malaki T’Olu K’Waig, which name literally means “man at the head of the river”. Malaki is also the mythological firstborn of Tuglay and Tuglibong and is the Bagobo word for man in the same way that Bia, Malaki’s sister, is the word for woman. In a sense, Malaki and Bia are even more appropriate archetypes of first man and first woman who became diwata or gods in the following legend of the founding of Sibulan.
The legend of Sibulan, the biggest Bagobo settlement in historic times, began with the passing of the Tuglay and Tugbilong an all the mona into the land of the diwata. Only the children of Tulay and Tugbilong were left in Sibulan. Then a long drought cam to pass upon the land so that the people could not plant their crops and famine soon stalked the Bagobo highlands. The children of Tuglay and Tugbilong began to leave their home and travel to other lands in pairs. As soon as any pair found a place to their liking, they settled there and begot progenies who became he ancestors of the other tribes in Mindanao.
One pair chose to remain in Sibulan even as the parched already could no longer provide for them. Then one day, as the man, too weak from hunger, hobbled across the barren fields in search of food, he saw a single stalk of sugarcane growing lustily in the midst of a scorched earth. As he cut the plant with his bolo (a long knife), fresh water gushed forth from its stalk and the fl w did not cease until both the couple’s thirst and the earth w re quenched and refreshed. From the plant’s abundant flow the rivers and the streams were once more filled with water until the rains fell to water the crops in the fields.
The palpable significance of the story lies in the mythological death and rebirth cycle: the passing of the mythical people as followed by the rebirth of new life in Malaki and Bia in Sibulan and by the other pairs of children of Tuglay and Tugbilong as founders of the other tribes in Mindanao. At the same time, a claim for some ethnic and cultural hegemony is implicit in the story which tells of the origins of the other tribes in Mindanao from the children of Tuglay and Tugbilong. The legend thus depicts an expansive stage in Bagobo mythological experience and a broadening of horizons from the confines of ethnic perspectives.
In the structure of Bagobo myth, the primordial ancestors, with the possible exception of the mona, were always represented in pairs Tuglay and Tugbilong, Malaki and Bia, and the children of the latter who departed from Sibulan, also in pairs, to become the heads of further progenies of the Bagobo. There are no androgynous figures in Bagobo mythology. The prominence of paired ancestors appears as a Bagobo valorization of the man woman tandem and the high value placed on the family and ancestors.
The differentiation of gender roles is strictly delimited as in the roles of Lumabat and Mebuyan. Fidelity to her chores made Tuglibong relentlessly scold the sun until it was offended and bolted away to unprecedented heights. Mebuyan’s refusal to go with her brother to the sky country underscores her own distinct role. Even as she plummeted in the opposite direction (to the land of the dead) she continued to perform her role, that of nourishing life.
The Myth of the Tagakaulo
The Tagakaulo are one of the native groups who inhabit the mountainous interiors of Davao del Sur province. They are said to have derived their name from their preferred type of settlement, i.e. the origins or headwaters of rivers and mountain streams. The rootword is ulo which means head. This was an explanation given by a missionary account in the 19th century and which in the course of modern day research we were able to validate.
In 1987, the fourth volume of Tambara, the Ateneo de Davao University Journal, was being prepared as a special commemorative issue for the anniversary of the missionary Fathers of the Foreign Mission Society of Quebec (PME). The PME Fathers have had a long history in Davao and for this special issue the editors of the Tambara were invited to Lanipao, one of the PME missions among the Tagakaulo. We were asked to document the mission and undergo a sort of immersion process that would give us a feel of the mission. The documentation of their missionary works was to be contextualized in the history of Davao, an exciting enterprise since we were about to merge the writing of religious and secular histories.
About an hour’s drive from the Malita Parish, the trail to Lanipao started from a small stream. Our party alighted at a lay leader’s house in Talugoy and from there we picked up the trail. For the first two hours we followed the course of the stream, walking sometimes on its banks but most of the time in the stream itself. After a while, the significance of the name Tagakaolo (dwellers of the origins of rivers) dawned on us; we were following the river or the stream to its source up in the mountains.
The PME Fathers follow a strict pattern of inculturation before beginning to work in a mission. They all have to learn to speak the native tongue. One of the Fathers was Fr. Gilles Belanger who was assigned to work among the Tagakaolo of Sangat, Malita. Fr. Belanger lived with a native Tagakaulo family for four months in order to learn the language. He said the the Tagakaulo responded easily when one talked to them about their native culture. The Tagakaulo culture, like any other native culture, is steeped in oral traditions which in turn are reflective of their collective experience or history as a people. In the last century, the Tagakaulo were said to have held the region between Malalag and Lais in the southwestern part of the Davao Gulf. Being upland dwellers, they were barred from the sea by the Manobo and Muslims who lived along the coast, while in the mountains they had to contend with the powerful group of the B’laan, another indigenous group of the Davao Region.
In Fr. Pastell’s Mapa Ethnografico the Tagakaulo were described as being more or less the peers of the Bagobo in terms of industry, but without the cruelty of the latter, who were known to practice human sacrifice. In particular, the missionary account praised the Tagakaulo widowers who were known as brave warriors displaying much courage in the battlefield. This was because according to Fr. Pastell, being a good warrior was an index of male attractiveness and desirability. Tagakaulo widowers who were eager to be remarried had to demonstrate their prowess in the battlefield in order to obtain a new wife or wives. The missionary account also mentioned the sub-groups of the Tagakaulo: the Kalagan (Kagan) and the Loac, the latter being very primitive and described as cimarrones.
Sometime during the latter half of the 19th century, the heretofore scattered groups of Tagakaulo from Malalag to Lais were said to have united under one chieftain whose name was Paugok. This was ostensively due to inter-tribal conflicts with the Bagobo against whom they waged war successfully with the result that the Bagobo were driven from the rich valley of Padada and Balutakay. The establishment of Tagakaulo settlements in these valleys resulted in their prolonged exposure to Kulaman Manobo and Moro. They Tagakaulo had friendly relations with these two groups. They were probably friendlier with the Moro than with the Manobo for at the turn of the present century the accounts of the Tagakaulo described their culture as being strongly influenced by the Moro or Muslim. The influence of the Moro among the Tagakaulo was so great that they not only adapted the Moro style of dressing but also substituted cotton for hemp in the manufacture of their garments. During this time, the Tagakaulo were recognized by their close fitting suits of red and yellow stripes from which the word Kagan was derived
In 1897, Malalag, together with two other reducciones, Balutakay and Piape, was being prepared for conversion into a pueblo or town status along the Kulaman coast. A census was taken of the houses in twenty-one reducciones in the area. Here, the native Tagakaulo of Malalag used to engage the Moro in frequent and sanguinary conflicts. The arrival of the first Spanish colonists worsened the lot of the Tagakaulo who became the prey of the latter in the traffic of slaves. Eventually, because of these insufferable conditions, the Kulaman coast was depopulated of its native populations. In particular, the Tagakaulo fled to the interior and upland regions. Thusm the Christianization of the Tagakaulo of Malalg originally started from the uplands and not in the coastal areas. In 1891, the reducciones or resettlements of the Tagakaulo in Malalag and Malita were given pueblo status.
In the American period, the Kalagan Tagakaulo lived on the American plantations along the padada and Balutakay rivers. The Kalagan remained on friendly terms with their Tagakaulo kinsmen and, except for professing the Islamic faith were in every way like the Tagakaulo in language,custom, and oral traditions.
A tribal historian of the Tagakaulo has said that they were descended from Lakbang and Mengedan and their wife Bodek. At the beginning, the three lived on a small islang in the sea. Later, two children were born and they in turn becane the parents of two birds, the kalaw and the sabitan. These birds flew away to other places and returned with bits of soil which their parents patted and molded with their hands until they formed the earth. Other children were born and from them came all other people who came to inhabit the island.
Two powerful spirits, Diwata and Tiumanem, watched the formation of the earth and when it was completed the latter spirit planted trees upon it. Each year he spent the spirits Layag and Bangay as stars to tell the people when to prepare the fields for planting. Other spirits, less friendly than these two, also existed. One named Siling caused much trouble by confusing travellers, thus causing them to lose their way in the forest.
Spirits of the unborn known, as the Mantianak, were believed to wander through the forest crying “Ina-a” (mother) and often attacked human beings. The only defense was to run to the nearest stream and throw water on their abdomen. The spirit Larma owns the deer and the wild pigs and is kind to hunters who offer him the proper gifts. Failure to make such offerings could result in getting lost or injured. Mandalangan, the warrior god of the Tagakaulo, is identical with the Bagobo Mandarangan.
Kawe are the shades of souls of the dead, the chiefs of whom were the ones who created the earth. In life, the kawe live in the body but, after death they go to the sky. They return to earth at certain seasons, usually during times when the rice fields need to be protected and guarded.
The baylan or priestesses can talk to spirits and from them have learned the ceremonies which the people should perform at certain times of at crucial periods in life. The rituals for birth, marriage, and death are similar to those of the Kulaman Manobo. A slight variation was noted by the anthropologist Faye Cooper Cole after a rice planting at Padada when all the workers placed their planting sticks on an offering of rice and then poured water over them. Another difference was noted in the rituals following the death of a warrior. A knife lies in its sheath beside the body and can only be drawn if it is to be used for sacrificing a slave. If such an offering is made it is usually carried out in the same manner as among the Bagobo. If it is impossible to offer a slave, a palm leaf cup is filled with water and is carried to the forest. Here, the relatives dance and then dip the knife and some sticks in the water “for this is the same as diping them in blood:. According to custom, warriors must go to fight once a year when the moon is bright.
The Mandaya of Caraga
In the 19th century, Spanish missionary account identified the people of the eastern coast of Mindanao as the Caragans. They were described as “an honorable people, peace-loving, respectful, obsequious, docile, submissive, and patient.” Their complexion was brown and sometimes white and their noses were tall and even aquiline. The men grew the hair in their head as long as the women’s but they trimmed their long beards with pincers. Their kinglets were called Hari-hari or Tigulang and were said to occupy their social station on account of their wealth. The Hari-hari took precedence over the principal families who had their own followers or sacopes and was consulted and obeyed even by the gobernadorcillo and other Spanish officials in the locality. He alone had the power to declare war on others, demand satisfaction for insults to his ranch or famstead, and act as an arbiter and court of last appeal after hearing the opinion of the principales in the trials of subordinates. It appeared that the Caragans retained their traditions and native institutions up until the 19th century. The writer of the account attributed this to the close family ties among them. Relatives always sought to live close together. For this reason, they remained inseparable from their native beliefs and believed they would die if forced to abandon them to become Christians. Today, the Caragans are known as the Mandaya.
The Mandaya believe that Mansilatan, the principal god and father of Badla, descended from the heavens to create the world. Afterwards, his son, Badla, also came fown to protect and preserve the world against the evil spirits Pundaugnon and Malimbong (man and woman, respectively). A spirit known as Busao proceeded from Mansilatan and is said to animate fighting men or warriors known as bagani.
When the Mandaya wish to cure someone, priestesses known as bailan invoke Mansilatan and Badla in the religious sacrifice called balilic.
. . . Ten, twelve or more bailanes come together according to the speldor they want to give to the feast. A small altar of the diwata is previously erected in front of the house of the man who spends for the ceremony: the owner comes out with the huge hog and present it to the bailanes in the presence of 100 to 200 invited guest. The hog is set on the altar and bailanes, dressed meticulously for the occasion, immediately gather around it. The Mandayas next sound (the) guimbao music consecrated to the diwatas, as the bailanes keep time with their feet, dancing around the hog and altar, singing “Miminsad”, etc. Shaking from head to foot and swaying from one side to the other, they form several semicircles with their movements. They raise the right arm tothe sun or moon, depending on whether it is day or night, praying for the intention of the patron … All at once the chief bailan separates from the others and pierces with her balarao the victim on the altar. She is the first to share in tha sacrifice, putting her lips to the wound to suck and drink the blood of the animal … The others follow and do the same . . . They return to their place, repeat the dance, shake their bodies, utter cries … (and) converse with Mansilatan who they say has come to them from heaven to inspire them in what they later prophesy.
It could be that the Mandaya’s creation myth was strongly influenced, and hence modified or altered, by Christian mythology. Caraga is the oldest town in Mindanao and has a history of colonization that dates back to the 16th century. The myth of a principal god creating the world is very similar to the Christian story of creation. The notion of gods being exclusively male is also familiar. Moreover, Badla, the son of Mansilatan, also came or descended to the world to protect and preserce it from the evil pair Pundaugnon and Malimbong. Finally, a spirit called Busao, which also originated from Mansilatan, completes the triumvirate.
On the other hand, the bailan, priestesses who officiate in various rituals and ceremonies, appear to be a survival of a more authoctonous tradition and institution. Bailan are diviners, healers, and soothsayers. The description of their roles in rituals, in which they dance, go into a trance and speak in strange voices, believed to be God’s, is strongly evocative of the shamanic techniques of ecstasy.
…during his trance, the shaman seeks to abolish this human condition that is, the consequences of the “fall” and to enter again into the condition of primordial man as it is described in the paradisiac myths. The ecstacy reactualizes, for a time, what was the initial state of mankind as a whole except that the shaman no longer mounts up to Heaven in flesh and blood as the promordial man used to do, but only in the spirit, in the state of ecstacy.
Comparative Analysis of the Three Myths and Conclusion
Of the three mythological creators, only the Tagakaulo made use of an agent, a bird which initiated creation by bringing some bits of soil to the gods who later fashioned it into the earth or the world. All three myths have more than one divinity invilved in creation, and among the three, the Bagobo mythology is distinguished for having the most number of creators, each with its own special creation. Only the Tagakaulo creation myth has a participant who is clearly interested in the welfare of man on earth. Tiumanem, one of the diwata who watched the formation of the earth, came down and planted trees. This diwata also sent the man who was the teller of the myth called Tiumanem “our oldest”, thus ascribing direct kinship between men and gods.
The Bagobo myth is alone (exceot for a T’boli variant) in the myth of Tuglibong, she whose scolding made the sun angry and precipitated its bolting to the high heavens and its present position. The outcome of this mythological event is however, unique in the annals of mythology. All over Southeast Asia and Oceania many similar myths tell the story about the sky being previously close to the earth. This element is regarded as a paradisaic motif, i.e. an expression of lost paradise, of rupture between heaven and earth or the cosmic schism. On the other hand, the outburst of Tuglibong led to a new beginning and a regeneration of life and the world. After the sun rose to its present height, the first people began to build houses on the earth’s surface instead of living in holes under the earth and the mona (primeval ancestors), who were already old, began to have babies!
The Bagobo mythical figure Lumabat has Higaonon and Tagakaulo variants. In the former variant, Lumabat was a folk hero who left the earth (or died) and then became a god himself who continued to provide useful knowledge to his people. In Malita, Davao del Sur, the Tagakaulo have been urging me to visit a place called Lumabat to see for myself his tima-anan or landmarks.
The Bagobo Lumabat is paired with a sister, Mebuyan, who refused to accompany him to the sky country. So, Lumabat went alone. The journey was long, arduous, and full of dangers and followed the typical pattern of a shamanic flight, i.e. descent to hell and final ascent to heaven. Upon reaching the sky country, Lumabat came upon a group of diwata chewing betel nut. As he approached, one of them spat betel juice at his stomach and immedately, Lumabat’s intestines disappeared. From then on he was never again bothered by hunger. Lumabat, of course, became a god himself. This, too, is a pattern of shamanism, Lumabat might have been a great shaman.
In the Mandaya mythology, the various rituals and ceremonies officiated by the bailan invoke the gods Mansilatan and his son, Badla. Although the Bagobo were also known to have the mabalian, priestesses who guard the secrets of their ancestors, their activities have not been described as prominently as have the Mandaya bailan. The bailan in Southern Borneo are acknowledged shamanesses or female shamans, who like the Mandaya bailan, invoke the gods through ecstatic techniques, fall into a deep trance and make prophecies.
Eliade considers shamanism as a great religious tradition among Asiatic peoples, although shamanic phenomena are by no means limited only to them. As a religious experience, shamanism pertains to the genre of “nostalgia for lost paradise”.
… the most representative mystical experience of the archaic societies, that of shamanism, betrays the Nostalgia for Paradise, the desire to recover the state of freedom and beatitude before the “the Fall”, the will to restore communication between Earth and Heaven; in a word, to abolish all the changes made in the very structure of the Cosmos and in the human mode of being by that promordial disruption. The shaman’s ecstacy restores a great deal of the paradisiac condition.
By means of special techniques, the shaman endeavors to rise above the present condition of man and to re-enter the state of primordial condition described in the paradisiac myths. Shamanism is the counterpart of Judeo-Christian mysticism.
From an ethnological perspective, the myths of the Bagobo, Tagakaulo, and Mandaya show a uniqueness adn distinctiveness which is significant considering a number of factors, e.g. interenthnic or mixed marraiges among them and overlapping geograohical boundaries. Although the Bagobo and the Tagakaulo occupy contiguous areas in Davao del Sur and have been known to marry across cultural boundaries within the last one hundred years, their creation myths are clearly distinct from one another. The Bagobo has the most number of creators; the Tagakaulo creators consist of a family of two husbands and their wife, and children which are birds. The Mandaya creator is a father-god.
On the other hand, if we take a broader look at the religious pantheons, we will note some close similarities among the gods. Tiumamen of the Tagakaulo is identical with the Bagobo Eugpomolok Manobo while Lumabat has a Tagakaulo variant. This would seem to leave the Mandaya out of the picture, were it not for the bailan, the Mandaya shamaness. The bailan appears to be an indigenous substratum in the Mandaya tradition. As a pre-Christian institution, it has survived Spanish colonization and Christianization. Lumabat of the Tagakaulo and Bagobo might have been a great shaman. It would seem that shamanism is a unifying element in the religious experiences of the three. As an intensely religious experience, shamanism owes nothing to western mysticism although sharing in its spiritual and religious attributes. If we agree with Eliade, who said that the sacred never ceases to manifest itself, here then is a meeting point between pre-Christian and Christian beliefs.
In what way do these mythologies address ecological concerns?
In covert and sometimes overt terms, the myths of the Bagobo, Tagakaulo,and Mandaya tell us about the meaning and significance of nature in their lives and how they relate to it. The Bagobo gods are guardians of specialized creations, e.g. earth, mountains, water, etc. Each element of the natural environment is regarded as having deeply spiritual attributes and is in fact animated or held to have a life of its own. Spectacular features of the landscape, as in the case of Mt. Apo, exert a powerful influence in their lives, more so because the spirits who were supposed to dwell there were anthropomorphised. In this case, the relationship becomes institutional or social as between fellows in the same social group. The myth of Tuglibong and the sun is particularly interesting. Agricultural peoples commonly weave their myths around celestial bodies which, to a great extent govern their agricultural and economic activities. However, the story of Tuglibong reveals a perception of the sun as a not too benign entity. The Bagobos are known to worship the sun. Even the grim practice of human sacrifice has an ecological significance, nature’s bounty is not free. The Bagobo have to propitiate the gods of Mt. Apo with offerings of human victims in exchange for a bountiful harvest and valor in the battlefield.
The Tagakaulo construed the world as having been molded from bits of soil brought by a bird. Of the three myths, this is probably the most worldly or earthly. That the world as created is less than perfect may be inferred from the act of planting trees on it by one of the diwata that watched the formation of the earth.
Although the bailan experience is spiritual, a motif in the shamanic dance is particularly unusual. The Mandaya bailan calls upon the god to come down instead of her going up: “Miminsad, miminsad, Mansilatan”. (“Come down, come down, Mansilatan:) an insight to a most earthbound worldview.
Ethnohistory and Culture Change among the Bagobos: Some Preliminary Findings*
Introduction
Ethnohistory is essentially the welding of contemporary ethic data to information obtained from historical documentation. Such an approach enables one to probe historical meaning or significance over and above the historical records, thereby enhancing one’s research to the point where one is allowed to traverse to historical continuum from one end to the other, or from past to present.
In another sense, ethnohistory is the collective experience of an ethnic group. The word ethnic refers to certain culture, Lingual, or physical characteristics that pertain to a group of individuals. Such agglomeration is usually small, and term ethnic group in the context of modern societies denotes minority groups, those small enclaves of traditional and pre-modern communities that have endured and are sometimes regarded as exotic and trouble survivors of a long, forgotten past.
The case for ethnohistory in Philippines historical writing is founded on one of the more critical issues in Philippines historiography today. Heretofore, Philippines history has strained to be understood in terms of what is historically meaning to Filipinos. The historical past purports to be a collective past, the totality of what is considered as the common experience of the Filipino as a people or nation.
Yet, the Filipino past is not a single, homogeneous experience. There has been a variety of historical stimuli to elicit a variety of historical responses and idiosyncratic experience even as the same or similar historical events produced unique responses. Ethnohistory rests its claims on Philippines ethnic plurality and seeks to understand the dynamism of ethnic traits and attributes vis-a-vis historical phenomena. The plurality of Philippines society today underlies the multiple cleavages that characterize its structure.The concept of ethnicity is that of small group identities that persist inspite of and at times, in utter disregard of the preeminent idea of nation or state. The challenge of non history is the challenge for every Filipino to grasp the totality and vastness of man experience. The totality and homogeneity of historical experience are not one and same thing.
The Bagobos at the Time of Spanish Contact
The original of the Bagobos lies, up to this time, veiled in anonymity. The state of prehistorical and archaeological research in Davao or for that matter the whole of Mindanao is such that historical Material regarding the origin of the various indigenous groups has remained niggardly and therefore insufficient. One of the two known archaeological survey conducted in southeastern Mindanao was the archaeological excavation of the Talikud Caves of Davao Province in 1972.The survey was reportedly a part of a long term program to explore and test archaeologically the broad triangular area from southeast Mindanao, northern Sulawesi, and the western end of Irian Jaya including Moluccas in order to investigate the movement of Austronesian-speaking peoples as well as the cultures that are found in the spread of Malay tradition.
The explorations in the Davao area were conducted in the provinces of Davao provinces, Davao Oriental and Davao del Sur. The specific sites were some caves found on the island facing Davao City. Some of the finding are significant in that they purport to pertain to the pre-history of people in southeast Mindanao, and Solheim has proposed that the area of origin of proto-Austronesians was somewhere within the island area of Palawan island in the west, southern Mindanao, Sulawesi, and Irian Jaya.
By and large the most significant finds in the Davao area were the rock sites of Talikud island to be the earliest sites of the excavation. The shell finds at the Talikud shelter were found to have been used over a considerable period of time.A few flaked stones not natural to the shelter suggested a flaked skill tradition the same as that of the west cost of Palawan and the Sulu Archipelago.
The Spanish Conquest of Davao
The conquest of Davao in 1849 allowed the Spaniards to make inroads into the Gulf’s vast interiors in search of trade and native converts who could be won over to populate the Christian settlements that were soon to be establish all over the Gulf area. Davao at the time was inhabited by native Muslims groups and those whom the Spaniards termed Infieles, the native who were neither Muslims nor Christian. Among these the Bagobos constituted one of the more numerous groups some of whom became the first Christian converts.
Up until the early 1880’s , the Spaniards had not sufficient acquainted themselves with their Bagobo converts to be able to describe them with any degree of familiarity except to note with mounting apprehension the fact that the Bagobos practiced human sacrifice. Towards the ends of this decade however, the presence of a more permanent missionary i.e,a parish priest in Davao enabled the missionaries to observe the Bagobos with a little more intimacy. By then a breaking through has been made in the recorded history of the Bagobos.
The Bagobos were found to be principal inhabitants of the Davao mountain range and in particular of Mt. Apo, a dormant volcano in whose folds the Bagobos built their rancherias or farmhouses. Along the coast they also lived in settlements such as Labo, Binugao, Cauit, Melilla etc., and in some like Daron, they lived along side other native groups. Both upland and lowland Bagobos were known to practice human sacrifice quite frequently, the object of their propitiatory activities being a local deity called Mandarangan, who together with his consort, Darago , was believe to love in the great volcano itself. The crater of this volcano is covered by a dense fog during most of the day and from its bowels columns of sulphur and smoke continually shoot up. Such a sight must have been most awesome for the Bagobos, evoking among them the first and primal stirrings of the ineffable. A Jesuit missionary in the 1860’s one described the crater as resembling an immense sacrificial altar.
The first visit of the Spaniards to a Bagobos house was in the house of Manib, Datu of Sibula. The visitors found themselves in a windowless tree-house, its dimly lit interiors offering few comforts. A platforms. A platform like elevation was the only architectural feature that intruded on the simplicity and modesty of the single chamber. On this platform, the guest were receive by Manib, surrounded by this family. In the presence of visitors, he took care to impress them with a display of his household wealth. The platform on which he and his family sat was covered with native women cloth or blankets while pieces of large Chinese porcelain plates were conspicuously at various points in the room alone with the agongs and other musical instruments. The plates and the agongs were highly priced goods. A native iron forge was likewise forge was likewise noted by the Spaniards.
The Spaniards were more impressed with the ancient genealogy of Manib, and his father Pangilan, a very old man at this time. The Spanish missionary placed the age of Pangilan at about a hundred years. As a young man he was said to have made a wedding present of 100 pairs of human ears, a token of a hundred human victims, to his bride. A few years later,when Pangilan died, Manip together with all his relatives refused to lift the lalaoan or periods of mourning until seven slaves had been sacrificed and their blood poured over Pangilan’s grave.
The Bagobos were distinguished from other native groups as being the most fastidious dressers.The Bagobo was always dressed elegantly from head to foot. Men and women were adorned with earings, necklaces, bracelets, armlets and anklets of beads,shells, or precious metals such a gold. Around the waist, they usually wore a wide belt of cloth on which are sewn hundreds of tiny bells cascading from the torso so that the least movement produced a pleasant and most fascinating sound. They matched their ornaments with a serious and regal air about them.
By now,it had become apparent that the Bagobo social structure was dominated by a warriors class known as magani, the Datu himself being chief magani among them. It was the Datu as magani who decided when to proclaim the yearly festivities that ended in sacrificing enemies and other human victims. Only magani participated in the rites of paghuaga. Although the social organization recognize the regional role of a shaman in the mabalian who performed the lesser rituals and ceremonies, it was the Datu who as chief magani officiated in the most important rites of the community.
A man’s aim in life was to become a magani, which was itself the very essence of manhood. He who has killed a number of his enemies was set off from the rest of the community by certain special tokens. He who has killed two or more persons was distinguished for the deed by being allowed to wear the blood-red shirt and the chocolate colored headgear. Those who have killed four were privileged to wear the blood-red trousers, and those who have killed up to six wore the complete outfit of blood-red shirt, trousers, headgear and in addition carry a small bag of the same color in which are placed betel nut and lime for chewing. The missionaries worked hard to stand out the practice but confessed that their efforts towards this bore little success,were strongly reminiscent of those that the Spaniards first saw in the Philippines in the 16th century. Instead of compact and permanent villages, the Bagobos lived in farmhouses set far apart from one another. The field were planted to rice, abaca and sugarcane, Among the men were artisans such as goldsmiths and carpenters while the women were weavers of abaca, piña, tindog, and wrought fine embroideries.
Almaciga, a local resin was the principal forest product which together with wax constituted the chief exports of the region. The Bagobos were known as keen traders and usually produced an excess of local manufacturers for purposes of trade. They traded hemp made from the native abaca, betelnut, knives, and other crafted tools as well as weapons from the native forge. Bagobo knives were highly priced for their fine craftsmanship. The incoming trade with the Muslims and Christian brought back iron posts, copper wires, Chinese porcelain, salt, and animals. Aside from the coastal trade with the Muslims Bagobos also traded with other native tribes in organized trade parties that visited other settlements after customary notices had been given.
Acculturation: The Contact Situation
From the start, the colonization and Christianization of the Bagobos was an uphill struggle that produced no appreciable gains for the first twenty or thirty years. This was largely due to the sporadic and intermittent patterns of contact that hardly enabled the Spanish presence to make any impact. Town-making proceeded at a slow.uncertain pace while the conversion of the native inhabitants lagged behind weighted down as it were by a malady chronic to the pacification of the Philippines in the early centuries of conquest -the remontados, those whom the Spaniards branded as apostates of the Catholic faith and fugitives of the Christian reducciones or settlements.
An exception to this dismal and frustating procedure was the settlement of Lobu. This was also a large coastal settlement of Bagobos along coast of the Gulf which in the 1880’s came close to fulfilling Spanish dreams of a model Christian settlement populated by native Bagobo converts. Lobu had fresh water springs, an excellent anchorage’ and a population that was more or less sedentary and already raising crops such as corn, tobacco,bananas, and root crops, In 1884, Lobu became the town of Sta. Cruz. The ceremonies in the founding of the new town were graced by the presence of the Government of Davao and his wife and made more impressive by the sight of the Spanish gunboat,”Gardoqui,” which brought the Spanish governor and his wife to the shores of the new town.
The founding of Lobu, a Jesuit into the Town of Sta. Cruz owed much to the effort of Fr. Matthew Gisbert, a Jesuit missionary who visited Davao for the first time in 1880, having inherited the charge of converting its infieles from Fr. Quirico More of the same Society of Jesus. Fr More had been the missionary of Davao for some time and had already built a chapel in the Bagobo settlement of Tuban. In the same year, Fr. Gisbert was able to persuade the Bagobos of Tagabuli, Binaton, and Balalon to form a reduccion in Lobu. The priest had agreed to live the Bagobos in Lobu endeavoring to root out their “infidelity” i.e., paganism. It must have been this condition that softened the resistance of the Bagobos and made them receptive to the idea of resettlement. In addition, the missionary had brought his own provisions: plenty of rice and other supplies. The Bagobos agreed to work in weekly turns receiving a share of the Father’s goods at the end of the week. After a month’s work they were able to clear a wide path from the shore to river Tabing, their source of drinking water . Then a chapel, dedicated to St. Joseph,was built. A school teacher, Angel Brioso, was appointed for the education of the children of the new settlement.
In 1898, when the Jesuits of Mindanao were called back to Manila due to the outbreak of the Philippines revolution, the town of Sta. Cruz was left in the care of Angel Brioso. For reasons unexplained in the missionary account, Angel Brioso, in collusion with other Visayan Christians and Muslims collaborators, destroyed the town left to his charge, melting its bell and other church items and afterwards dividing the metal between him and his friends. Brioso and his friends had previously declared themselves insurrectos or rebel.
When Fr. Gisbert returned to Sta. Cruz after the revolution, all that remained of his church were its posts. The greater and more productive part of the town had become the property of a certain Lt. Thomas who was the head of the first American military contingent to arrive in Sta. Cruz. The Lieutenant installed Angel Brioso as a municipal head of sorts of the town. Despite its setbacks,Fr. Gisbert was forced to concede that the town recovered and became once again prosperous by virtue of government fiat. The inhabitants were compelled to open new streets to make way for new establishment such as trading houses.The missionary account betrayed a tinge of sorrow as it noted the growing strength of Protestantism in Sta. Cruz from 1904 onward.
The story of Sibulan was not carefully chronicled unlike that of Sta. Cruz of Lobu Sibulan was made into a reduccion some time in 1876 and renamed Santillana. In 1889. Manib was arrested by cuadrilleros or soldiers of the colonial government for refusing to provide an auxiliary of Bagobos to aid in the capture of a Bagobo fugitive of the reduccion of Astorga. Manib was likewise charge with impeding the latter’s capture and was confined in the local jail for sometime.
Some Spanish authorities worried about the lack of prudence in the arrest and incarceration of a Bagobo datu with good reason. After Manib’s release the Spaniards that the Bagobos had sacrificed another human victims in the highlands of Sibulan and killed as well those who were responsible for the Datu’s humiliation. After this, Manib and his followers razed their field and abandoned their rancherias taking care to lay traps and snares along the path of their pursuers.
Impact of Colonization
The political evolution of Davao from the Spanish reducciones to the American towns and trade center meant the gradual weakening of the tradition of the traditional structures. In the 1920’s Bagobo culture began yielding almost imperceptibly to change. With the death of the old datus like Manib, Bitil, and Tongkaling , the loose political system which was centered on the local rule of the datu slowly gave way to a new centralized macrostructure whose head was a strangely remote authority known as the provincial governor or the municipal mayor. Other factors such a demography and economic changes combined to force the Bagobos towards the inevitability of social and cultural transformations.
Up to 1919 the poblacion or center of Sta. Cruz was still a Bagobo community, the sprinkling of Visayas, Chinese, Japanese and American residents constituting a minority. The landscape was dominated by the familiar Talisay and Acacia trees and the municipal hall standing by the side of the old Catholic church as these building did some twenty years before in the Spanish colonial decades. Such colonial idyll however. could not long survive the implacable demands of modernization and change of the next period of occupation.
Under the Americans, more Christian settlements and centers where native goods could be traded were established. Two such trade centers were established in Sta. Cruz and Sibula. By 1907, Japanese homesteaders and abaca planters began coming to Bagobo lands. Japanese farmholdings burgeoned all over Bagobo settlements facilitated either through marriage with Bagobo women or the contravention of laws restricting the ownerships of the Philippines lands.
To counteract the growing strength of foreign immigration into Davao, the Commonwealth Government passed the Colonization Act of 1935 that encouraged Filipino in migration into virgin lands in Cotabato, Lanao, and Davao. In the 1930’s, Sta. Cruz was mostly populated by migrant workers employed in the Japanese and American plantations. Some 132 hectares of the poblacion area were owned by American veterans of the Philippines-American War of 1898. Sta. Cruz under the American grew to an extensive municipality composed of the present towns of Digos, Bansalan, Hagonoy, Padada, and all the known Bagobo settlement in the modern province of Davao del Sur. In the poblacion itself, the average landholding amounted to about five or six hectares, but in Digos and Padada, American landholding covered hundreds of hectares.Few Bagobos, however, worked in the foreign-owned abaca plantation. At about this time, they slowly started to disappear from their residences in the lowland poblacion. Cases of land disputes involving native Bagobos and Visayas multiplied. The most common of such conflicts were the adaption of coercive means to make the Bagobos clear forest lands for the new settlers and the migrate encroachments on lands already cleared by the Bagobos.
When the war broke out in 1942, the migrant temporarily fled Sta. Cruz to other coastal areas farther south while the Bagobos sought the refuge of the nearby mountains. When the whole country surrendered to the Japanese in May of the same year, most of the Visayans returned to their homes in Sta. Cruz especially when it was learned that the Japanese military would not occupy it. The Bagobos of Melilla, Binaton and other upland areas were made to organize the local KALIBAPI under a native District President. No effective guerrilla unit could be organized in the area mainly because many Japanese civilians had intermarried with Bagobos. After Liberation in 1945, most of the plantation owned by the American were sold to local Filipinos in Sta. Cruz. Among them were the Almendras and Bendigo families, formerly of Danao, Cebu City who have since then become the political leaders of the town. American anthropologist, Fay Cooper Cole and Laura Watson Benedict who had been observing the displacement of the Bagobos since 1916 noted that the ineluctable transformation of the Bagobos could not be held off for long. Some of the Bagobo experience during the last fifty years are best told by themselves.
Life Histories
Cesar Manapol
I was born in Binaton, formerly a part of Sta. Cruz this municipality, on November 20,1916. My father , Jose was a native of Tanjay, Negros Oriental who came to Davao in 1914 as a school teacher. He was a missionary trained in Siliman University and was a council and refuge of the Bagobos here in our area. My mother was a full-blooded Bagoba, whom my father met while he was school teacher in Melilla. I also met my wife in Malilla.
The word Lobu is pronounced Lab-o and means a water source. When I was a little boy, we often came down to Lobu from our home in Binaton. All the mountains have names i.e., Karatongan , karamagan, Boribid. I did not experience the tribal wars among the natives of Davao. I only know about them from what my elder used to tell us youngsters.According to my uncle, it was the Bilaan who the Tagabawas (Bagobos) usually fought. These “wars” were really stealthy raids in the dead of the night rather than face-to-face combats. I also remember the trade which native conducted with one another. Bagobos of Binaton usually traded with the “Kaolos” (Tagacaolos) and the kalangans. When I was a little boy, we used to come down from Binaton bringing camotes and other farm produce to be traded or bartered with the other tribes. The accustomed trading place in our area was Tuban. A trade day was agreed upon by interest parties by making arrangements with local datus. Once a date has been agreed upon, we tied a knot on apiece of string counted the days by such knot until the appointed time. Everyone is careful not too forget this date. whatever we brought back from the trade in Tuban was shared with our relatives who usually came around when they know you have just returned from the trade trip. This was the custom. Even datus have to share with other who been able to trade.
During the war, I was a soldier and therefore did not like the Japanese. Before the war it was alright. Some Bagobos were hired to work in the Japanese plantation Sibulan, Toril, Calinan, and Binaton all had Japanese haciendas. The workers were paid in cash as well as in kind. Some were permanently employed in Japanese families and were paid about ₱15 monthly, Two of my Aunts, both Bagobos, Sabina and Itik, married Japanese. Many more Bagobos who were married to Japanese during the war were “big shots” in Sta. Cruz. They occupied together with their families the biggest houses here during the war. After the war they had to leave Sta. Cruz, but their Japanese husband provided well for for them. Some have been taken to Japan.
Among the Bagobos, there were few rich people except those married to the Chinese. It is not true that a non-Bagobos can acquire or own Bagobos land through marriage with Bagobos women. A Bagobo women is allowed to inherit property, and in marriage it is the husband who administer their property. However, the wife continues to own the property Among Bagobos,inheritance is transferred from parents to children, but not from wife to husband. A son-in-law would be ashamed to claim land that belong to his wife.
During the later part of 1944 we returned to Melilla. I became a sergeant in the police force under the Philippines Civil Affairs Units (PCAU). After the war, there were many loose firearms. Consequently,there were many incidents of armed robbery . Even Bagobos also had loose firearms, although they used them for hunting game. In Sta. Cruz. I don’t remember any outstanding criminal cases after the war . Running amok Bagobos was common during this time . There was one case I remember–this was Buan whose wife ran away with another man. He killed two people before he was himself killed by the relatives who came to succor his victims. Before the war was certainly the better times.
Tawiling Bigkas
I was born on January 5,1931 in Baracatan, Davao der Sur. My parents were both Bagobos, but I am married to a Visayan, when I was a little girl,this place (Sibula) was still a forest. Most of the houses were styled according to “Bagobos” fashion. The first in our family to live here was my great-grandfather. During my father’s time the family occupation was farming. My mother, like the rest of our womenfolk, occupied herself with housework and weaving. I don’t remember having been scolded by my parents. I like to play a lot.
I experience working for the Japanese. The work was mostly clearing field. We were paid daily in kind: three salted fish, three leaves of tobacco, and one chupa of salt. we were seldom paid in cash. During the war we went back to our field and started all over again . I think the period before the war was a better time.For one thing our roads here in Sibulan were much better because the Japanese maintained them well through hard labor among us natives. There were few criminals incident. Today the Bagobos have” awakened”, and now we want our children to go school, know may things, be independent and work our own farms.
Datu Salumay
What I remember from the past are datus here in Salumay (Calinan, Davao City).Spanish soldiers something came to talk to our datus about game and other source of food. I think their purpose for being was the same as any other people-to look for one’s livelihood. We Bagobos are not too interested in other people or in what other people do. IN general we mind our own business and care only our own affairs.
Our place Salumay, is surrounded by mountains and forest. The names of our mountains are Mando and Malambo. We earn our living by farming and hunting. During this time there were only a few Cebuanos in our place. I don’t remember Americans living with us in this place. During the American period, our Datu was Dumokan. At this time Bagobos in our place began to sell their lands. We were living them in Simod by the side of the Bankerohan river.
When war broke out, I moved my family back to Salumay. Some “Filipino” also moved with us to this place from fear of the Japanese who have already occupied the city. During this time our Datu Sumba, The Japanese did not come to Salumay. We did not experience liberation in Salumay, but some American reached our place. They distributed clothes and food among us.
Some Preliminary Observations of Contemporary Bagobo Culture
During the 1975 census the Bagobos population numbered a total of 29,363, the concentrations of which are found in Davao City which claims 53% of the total population, Sta. Cruz with 26%, and the remaining 21% are found in three other municipalities of Davao del Sur. Sta. Cruz and Sibulan are political subdivisions of this province, Sibulan being a barangay of Sta. Cruz. Most, if not all, of the 15 barangays comprising Sta. Cruz today were known Bagobo settlements in the 19th century. Except for the poblacion or center , most of the barangays are in the highlands adjacent to the coast since the topography of Sta. Cruz is generally rolling and mountainous. It has a total land area of 27,960 hectares which is 6.71% of the total land area of the province.
The population of Sta. Cruz in the 1980 census is 48,272 with a density of 176 person per square kilometer. The population is characteristically young with the ages of 44 years and below comprising 47.3% of the age structure. Consequently, the municipality has a high dependency ratio of 96.60. Moreover , 74% of children between the ages of 0-6 months were found to be suffering from various levels of malnutrition . The major occupations are employment for the poblacion and farming for the majority of the barangays including the barangay of Sibulan. The prinipal crops grown are coconut and corn. None of the barangays has irrigation facilities.
Sibulan is 21 kilometer distant from the poblacion and has a population of 2,518 most of whom are engaged in upland farming . It is accessible by jeepney from the district of Toril in Davao City for the first nine or ten kilometers. The remaining three or four kilometers must be negotiated on foot along a sloping and increasingly rugged terrain. Along this road the traveller to Sibulan must negotiate three precipitous descents. The third traverses the Baracatan river which is actually no more than a mountain stream. On rainy days,this tiny stream can become a roaring gorge after an hour of heavy rain, impeding passage to Sibulan. Following the steep ascent from this river, one comes to Sibulan proper nestling high up in the Davao mountain range.
One’s first eyeful of Sibulan reveals the Barangay Hall built close at the edge of a precipice, a basketball court, and a cluster of empty huts surrounding an open cockpit On Saturday, the market day of Sibulan, these empty huts come to life and are suddenly filled with people. one arrive on horseback apparently from higher and more distant grounds. Except for some recent structures the landscape of the mountain walls and rising peaks surround the newcomer with ambiance of the tradition. The panorama of native flora: the smell of bamboo, the sight of the tall and stately durian trees, and the verdant turf everywhere , all seem to defy the passing of time.
Yet, there are no more trees houses in Sibulan, Today’s Bagobos houses are built on the ground , but foisted on piles instead of posts. The interior is usually divided into three or more section: a receiving area with one or two wooden benches for visitors, a kitchen, and an elevated and walled-off area for sleeping quarters. Today’s dwellings are also provided with windows. The house of the barangay captain is of the bungalow type. While the architectural types have given way to modern ones, the materials used are those that are derived from traditional sources. For roofing and walling , the old buho, a specie of bamboo which are plaited together for use as thatching material, it still very much in evidence. The Bagobos of Sibulan maintain that the buho is impervious to rain as well as sun.
One the other hand, settlement habits of old appear to have persisted. Houses are set far apart from one another. The clustering of two or more houses that are within calling distant of each other is of occasional incidence. When a group of houses are built close together this is usually because the owners are close relatives . An obvious reason for the dispersed pattern of residence it that each house is usually constructed in the midst of or adjacent to a garden of about 1000 to 2000 square meters planted to either rice or corn, some fruit trees, coconuts, bananas, and some vegetable. Such a pattern is strongly reminiscent of the rancherias of old which were built close to one’s rice fields and in which one’s immediate neighbors are family members.
Sibulan farmers are dry cultivators. Since there is no irrigation system for the entire municipality of Sta. Cruz, firing was and still is the only known means of soil cultivation. Necessarily, this has resulted in the cumulative degradation of the soil. Most of the old Sibulan folk whom I interviewed told us that the soil is not now as rich as before, and this is the reason why Sibulan folk seek a much higher ground on which to plant their rice. The affluent ones own bigger ricelands in Tabog, an almost vertical wall of green fields that rises high above Sibulan.
There are a number of small sari-sari stores selling soft drinks, beer, cigarettes,and other non-essential items. These stores are not selling basic goods since from observation each family is more or less self-sufficient in basic food such a rice and other staples. At harvest time, crops are stored in family granaries or sold at the market places in Davao City or Toril.
Today’s Bagobo’s are predominantly Christian. Many possess Christian names which is usually a token received baptism either from Catholic or Protestant rites. The practice of adapting the name of adapting the name of one’s father as a surname has gained currency,i.e.,Pedro Tongkaling is the son of someone whose only name is Tongkaling. A possible exception are the names of second or third ascending generation members who are still known by only one name. A Caholic priest comes to say mass on Sundays, while the Protestant chapel is served by a resident Pastor. The present generation of Bagobos hardly hardly react to the name of Mandarangan, unlike the older generations whose eyes would suddenly light up with an old intensity at the mention of the deity. Many Bagobos prefer to dismiss the subject by associating the old worship with works of the devil.
However, old habits die hard, and old practices become ritualized instead of merely ceasing to be . IN 1913 when the American anthropologist, Laura W. Benedict attended a Gin-Em, the longest and most elaborate of Bagobo festivals which culminate in human sacrifice, she noticed that the Bagobos who shot a chicken as offering said a prayer in apology for not being able to offer a human victims, a tradition which had already been proscribed by the American authorities.
Presently, a more powerful factor that could possibly bring about drastic changes among the Bagobos would be the political situation and the increasing social as well as economic pressures that it has brought to bear upon them, The activities of both the New People Army (NPA) and the military have greatly destabilized the area, the natural consequences of armed encounters between these two groups being the dislocation of noncombatants.
According to military documents, the first group of the Communist Party of the Philippines (CCP) was organized in Mindanao in June 1971. The group’s activities were intensified in Tagum, Davao del Norte and Digos, Davao del Sur. The following year the Mindanao Regional Party Committee (MRPC) organized, and by the end of 1982, the CPP had already established seven fronts in region XI. An ambush in Sulop, Davao del Sur on November 3,1982resulted in the death of Mayor Mondejar and several PC/INC personnel. The event also signaled the start of armed hostilities in the region.
The CCP/NPA operational viability relies much on the support of the people Reports of a systems of “progressive taxation” in which each family is asked to contribute ₱1.50 plus a chupa of rice depending on the economic conditions of the locality, have circulated freely since 1976. When moving about across territories in which insurgent influence has been fairly established, ranking party members pass the night in the houses of sympathizers. Upon the approach of intruders or any other stranger, an alarm is made in various ways such as dropping heavy objects on the floor, ringing of bells or agongs, disturbing chickens and other animals.
The other disruptive element is the military itself. To contain and neutralized the insurgent threats, the Regional Unified Command for Region XI (RUC) was organized on April 18,1983. The establishment of the RUC was a move to enhance the operational effectiveness of the military by coordinating and integrating all the Armed Forces in the Region. The first important operation was named katatagan which consists in a three pronged program.
a. Phase 1- Intensification of civil-military operation in unaffected areas to win the people to the side of the government while at the same time strengthening para-military forces and self-defense capabilities;
b. Phase 2-Intensification of civil-military operation in cleared areas previously influenced by the insurgents and the establishment of a civil defense force; and
c. Phase 3-Reconciliation. During
the third phase the military will rehabilitate previously affected areas with the help of other government agencies to ensure the acceleration of socio-economic growth in the region.
Today, the presence of these competing forces strains the peace and tranquility of the Bagobos who are only now being made aware the larger political realities around them.The advent of centralized rule has not really made itself felt among the cultural minorities until recently. The institution of the datu system as known to the Bagobos appeared to have been restricted to mediation and arbitration rather than outright rule. Up until modern times, the only familiarity that Bagobos have with political authority is that of the datu, a local functionary whose authority did not normally exceed the number of his followers. In the past, an offending Bagobo could lose his life to the datu’s maganis under terms that had been specified to him by custom and tradition. The risk of losing his life to this personal enemies was probably greater than the former possibility.
Today’s festering political conditions have made the Bagobos more vulnerable in his struggle for survival. They have magnified life’s uncertainties by exposing him to forces over which he has neither choice nor control. In a bid to draw the Bagobo to the larger mainstream of the national and society, the system is unwittingly making use of methods that would destroy the very milieu that nurtures hi. The system claims justification through a known principle of social theory, that of the mutuality between individual and society.
On the other hand, the unwholesome atmosphere is driving many Bagobos to lowland barangays where they are drastically and inexorably torn from their traditional lifestyles. Thus,the present disorders many yet prove to be the propelling force that could bring the Bagobos to integration or assimilation into the larger Filipino society. When that happens, it would appear that their integration has been achieved at the cost of their genuinely Filipino tradition and culture.
Culture Change and Adaptation of the Manobo and Bagobo of Mount Apo National Park
Introduction
This is a descriptive ethnographic study of culture change and adaptation of the Manobo and Bagobo of Mt. Apo National Park. The Manobo and Bagobo exist in a local milieu which is dominated by the lowland settlers. The relocatees do not command political and economic powers because of their simple agricultural technology, kin based social organization and position as indigenous tribes.
The natives of Mount Apo subsisted in the past on swidden agriculture, hunting and gathering of wild plants and animals. Today, they are engaged in cash crop production, though they still subsist in swidden agriculture.
Due to the NPA attack against a military patrol base on the project site on June 2, 1992, the native families transferred to the Relocation Site in advance. Temporary shelters were provided by the PNOC. They were followed by six resident families. At the time of the attack, the relocation package deal had not yet been approved by the affected Manobo and Bagobo families.
The Census of 1990 shows that there are an estimated 6,278 Manobo and 1,226 Bagobo covering the three towns of Kidapawan, Magpet and Makilala of North Cotabato.
The research study was undertaken in a settlement of 21 families at the Relocation Site, Agco, in the barrio of Ilomavis, Kidapawan, North Cotabato. They are refugees from their homeland, due to their being displaced because of the Mindanao Geothermal Project.
This ethnographic study of the Manobo and Bagobo of Mt. Apo National Park undertook a baseline characterization of the cultural, economic, social, political and resource management system of the indigenous communities within and around Mt. Apo National Park; made assessments of the level of the socio-economic and cultural development of the cultural communities or indigenous tribes vis-à-vis the mainstream ethnolinguistic groups; and identified and recommended social intervention for the development of these peoples.
The installation of the Geothermal Project in the national park in Mt. Apo is a classic example of culture change and adaptation for indigenous tribes, such as the Manobo and Bagobo tribal groups. It is also an experience of displacement from their ancestral home and, at the same time, of how they have become adapted to new technologies. But there is an apparent danger to their traditional culture. It may result to assimilation of the Manobo and Bagobo cultures into the dominant lowland culture. It could be immensely valuable to researchers of the culture change and adaptation among tribal groups in the Philippines, this being a baseline study.
The ethnographer, with a research assistant, lived at the Relocation Site for a period of six months to facilitate the observation of their way of life and the gathering of the necessary data and information for the said duty. Likewise, the researcher made courtesy calls on the barrio captain and other local officials of Ilomavis and the Project Director of the PNOC Base Camp. Observations were made on important aspects of their life to find out how they have become adapted to the changes surrounding them. The major method was participant observation to gain a wholistic view of the Manobo and Bagobo community of Mt. Apo. Informal conversation was also made with the children, young people and old folks to obtain vital information to support the ethnographic study.
Key informants were utilized to provide relevant information on certain specific issues significant to the research study. They were native informants who truly spoke for themselves and were wholly acquainted with Mt. Apo and its environment.
Interviews of the PNOC staff and other important personalities were likewise employed in order to provide points of reconciliation on some important issues and discrepancies. Interviews were conducted among the Manobo and Bagobo women to ascertain the changing role of the women in their society.
In addition, photographic records of important events were obtained thru camera and video to ensure proper documentation of the said events. Maps of important sites were used to have tangible evidence of existing vital features of the study.
The Findings of the Study
The Manobo and Bagobo have been shifting cultivators for centuries. Mt. Apo is their ancestral home where they have lived in freedom, hunting and gathering wild plants and animals. Exchange of foods, crops, rice and other things is a tradition lived by’ the natives of Mt. Apo. They are also engaged in barter and trade with neighboring tribes.
Today, they are living in a non-traditionally clustered settlement. Plow agriculture. however, has not replaced their swidden cultivation of the kaingin. But they are engaged in cash crop production through gardening vegetables, especially cabbage, which they sell in the market. Unfortunately, the gardening system of the natives gave rise to dependency on the financier/comprador who shoulders the expenses for fertilizers. chemical, insecticides and pesticides. Though they share equally in the profit, the price set by the financier/comprador is lower than the market price. The native farmers can borrow money or credit goods from the financier.
The leadership of the tribal chieftain or datu must now give way to relations with lowlanders. They are now within the control of the local government. At the Relocation Site, two forms of control exist, namely, the traditional rule of the tribal chieftain and the local government. The natives of Mount Apo have gradually set aside their customary laws to give way to laws and other demands from the local government. Likewise, there is evident change in the role of Manobo and Bagobo women. They have assumed responsibilities which are new to them. The traditional social structures have been significantly and profoundly changed. However, the increasing poverty of the natives is miserably felt at the Relocation Site. Living with lowlanders has failed to economically uplift the condition of the Manobo and the Bagobo community. Consequently, thanksgiving rituals are no longer faithfully observed by them because they are quite costly. They have developed a pessimistic outlook due to their increasing poverty in re2tion to the lowlanders surrounding them.
The Manobo and the Bagobo communities face the possibility of a changing identity due to their being relocated in a lowland atmosphere. Conflict among them or with the dominant lowland population may evolve. There is also a growing emphasis on gambling and drinking which is a predominant influence on the natives.
New relationships exist between the natives and the westernized lowland settlers, as well as with development agents and the government. They are dominated by them. Furthermore, the relocatees are politically incorporated into the national body politi.que. Their pre-capitalist substinence economy is now transformed into cash crop production for market sale purposes.
On the religious aspect, the Church of Christ and Alliance groups have injected social changes, a few of which may not be culturally meaningful for the natives. Existing social organizations for the common good of the tribal communities and an NGO are not strongly felt by the relocatees. In addition, these religious changes felt by the natives may bring about assimilation to the dominant lowland culture. This is seen, for example in the obligation of natives to undergo a civil marriage in order to get the certificate needed by the children for school purposes. Thus, the Manobo wedding will gradually disappear.
The relocated natives were promised a priority of work according to the Memorandum of Agreement. But the relocatees are questioning why they have not become regular workers. Their contention is that it is due to their being natives. They made some remarks that it is easier for an Ilokano or a Visayan to be regularized than a native. They further added that they have been contractual workers. Even if the explanations are given it would be difficult for them to be regularized yet their contention prevails.
Maybe the PNOC could sponsor a training program for the indigenous tribes of Mt. Apo to improve their ability of work rather than for the natives to do it in secret.
There are four contractual workers at the Relocation Site and the rest are work -order workers. If an accident happens, they have no privilege like Medicare so they have to personally shoulder the hospital expenses. If, somehow, they can enjoy the privilege of Medicare, a lecture ought to be given to them to explain how the system works. The ethnographer is often consulted about SSS and how to process the Medicare.
However, when a program is planned for the natives, it ought to be adapted on their own setting because they differ from the westernized thinking of the lowland population.
The natives could be developed technically. They ought not to remain backward.
The main task of the government or any social organization is to promote for the common good of the members.
Within the period of six months living at the Relocation site, the writer discovered very significant changes in the life of the, Manobo and Bagobo of Mt. Apo. The indigenous tribes of M t. Apo were dislocated and are now resettled in a region where they have more interaction with the westernized lowland population. Because of their relocation the natives have given up their kaingin. However, as agreed upon by the affected families will be relocated. As of the completion of the ethnographic study, however, the relocatees have not yet received the land.
The absence of land has greatly affected the natives of Mt . Apo. If they have no work, farming the land can provide them with food in terms of rootcrops, corn and vegetables. There are as lut-ya or carlang. Cabbage is even cooked to sustain their hunger.
According to Philip Boeck, hunger, which indicates absence of support, solidarity and aid, is linked to egoism and withdrawal. The majority of the relocatees are in favor of the Geothermal Project. This proven by a survey conducted at the Relocation Site and those living at Anggue, Sudsuhayan and Sayaban. They voluntarily gave up their claim. Therefore, the indigenous tribes are also entitled for support and aid. Social services such as health, sanitation, education, youth program, home for the aged and others are some of the services to be intensified.
The indigenous tribes need social services since they are the forgotten people of the land. The rural areas are often at the tail end of any development program. Projects are more widespread in urban areas than in the rural areas. It is the prime responsibility of the so-called Christians to look after the common good of the cultural communities.
The aged are unattended and children have no chance for education because of poverty. One of the vital services needed by the natives is education. Anton Postma, in his work with the Mangyan of Mindoro, was guided by the principle that education is the first step towards development and integration. However, it must contain a different curriculum based on their culture, history and felt needs as indigenous tribes to enable them to acquire basic knowledge and skills for communication that would allow them to stand on equal footing with the lowland society: At the Relocation Site, the children have difficulty in going to school because of distance.
During rainy days they are absent since a good number of drivers do not allow them to ride in the service. Perhaps a school bus could be provided by PNOC so that children could avail themselves of the opportunity to be educated.
‘There is no a big problem for health because it is taken care by the Medical Officer at Base Camp. Many of the relocatees suffer from sickness, malnutrition and lack of medicine. The TB Control Program provides the relocatees with examination and X-Ray. But a good number of relocatees are not faithful in taking the medicine. They hide the tablets and capsules and continue to smoke and drink. However, with regard to eye and dental problems, a special medical program, could be arranged for the relocated, consisting of free consultation, medical, dental and eye examination.
The common ailments at the Relocation Site are fever. cold, cough, and diarrhea. An on-going orientation program might be given to the parents regarding health, nutrition and sanitation in coordination with the Bureau of Health. The natives ought to understand the value of cleanliness, beautification and sanitation, especially since Mt. Apo is a tourist spot.
The Geothermal Projects of PNOC are not always found in regions where there are cultural communities. The Mindanao Geothermal Project of PNOC is a special case. It is the home of the Manobo and Bagobo tribes. It requires a special kind of development, where top priority is given the indigenous communities. The development program ought to respond to the needs, hopes and aspirations of the cultural tribes. The natives must be involved in the formulation of program objectives so that it can truly be a development program of their own. A minority culture might be able to adapt creatively to a situation of dependency under the guidance of non-government organizations. Unfortunately, the NGO’s of Mt. Apo are not visibly felt by the ordinary natives. PNOC and the NC Os should strive to develop their self-reliance and independence. Ultimately, they should be able to stand on their own.
The indigenous tribes of Mt. Apo have become dependent on PNOC . They are not skilled workers. The supervisors ought to be on the look out for natives who show ink rest in their work. They can then initiate a training program to help those natives learn more about their work. Consequently, this will encourage and uplift the Manobo and Bagobo to become skillful in the job assigned to them.
The survey showed that a good number of the relocatees have no knowledge of the program of OSCC. Within a period of six months, the Provincial Director of OSCC has only visited the Relocation Site once.
The NGOs created at Mt. Apo ought to monitor the cultural, educational and livelihood programs for the natives. Consultations is a vital factor. Often times the natives are left out in the discussion and planning of projects. The officials think for the natives; the natives do not think for themselves. As a consequence, the natives do not actively participate during meetings.
The seven native women involved in the loom weaving project sponsored by the Mt. Apo Foundation(MAFI), and NGO are discouraged because of conflicts and difficulties. There is an utmost need for the head of the office to make visitations of the Site to know their problems.
The scholarship program is not widespread. There is only one college student at the Relocation Site who is a scholar. Five High School students graduated this year. They have difficulty in continuing their studies because of poverty. They are interested in the MAFI scholarship program but they do not know the process involved. Perhaps an orientation could be given to the young people at the Relocation Site.
An Overview of Cultural Research on Mindanao
Cultural studies and research properly belong to the social sciences particularly the disciplines of ethnology, anthropology, archeology, and more recently, ethnohistory or culture change. A study of culture removed from its societal and human moorings is no longer acceptable hence, even in archeology where the primary focus is on artifacts, or the remains of man’s material culture as evidence of the past of the community or society, the relative value of the archeological evidence lies in the information or insights that it can provide by way of elucidating the lifestyle or culture of the people to whom it belongs. Cultural research would then presume an underlying and ultimate interest in understanding man through a study of his culture. Indeed, it would not be an overstatement to say that man is only understandable through his culture.
Scientific cultural research in Mindanao was started by American anthropologists who arrived in the Philippines during the first decades of the present century. Otley Beyer, Fay Cooper Cole and Laura Watson Benedict were some of the earliest scientist who pioneered the study of culture in these parts. The very proliferation of cultural groups indigenous to the island of Mindanao and Which at the time of Beyer, Cole and Benedict were practically in pristine stages served as the beacon to the first cultural studies undertaken.
We must not forget to mention the non-American and less scientific sources and writers such as the Spanish missionaries who preceded the American anthropologists. The Recollects and the Jesuits may not have been writing in any scientific or anthropological sense but their descriptions of the customs of the various “nations” so called in Mindanao are veritable sources of ethnographic and anthropological material that make up the substance of a baseline study. As every social scientist knows, studies of culture and social change are only as good as the available matrix or baseline data.
Unfortunately, most of the results of these studies have long ago been repatriated to the respective homelands of their foreign authors. A good example of this is the famous “Newberry Collection” at the Regenstein Library in the University of Chicago Illinois. A few researchers were gracious enough to leave copies of their works in Manila libraries and the National Archives.
After the war,and for reasons that can only be inferred or surmised, interest in cultural studies on Mindanao considerably waned. A small number of trained Filipino anthropologists who were based in Manila universities turned up some exciting volumes on the cultural groups of the Cordilleras and Luzon in general but cultural research on Mindanao was conspicuously lacking. Some of the notable exceptions to this Luzon-centric interest were Espiridon Manuel who produced four book on the Bagobos (actually Guiangans) and Manobos of Davao and Marcelino Maceda and Rudolf Rahmann who studied the Mamanuas of Lake Mainit in the Surigao area. Linda Burton, an archaeologist based in Xavier University in Cagayan de Oro City, likewise performed a highly creditable work in the excavations of the pre-historic balangay in Butuan City the results of which are now contained for posterity in the Butuan City the results of which are now contained for posterity in the Butuan Historical Museum. My own modest contributions to contemporary cultural research on Mindanao is the Bagobos of Davao … the results of a five-year study of the Tagbawa Bagobo of Davao del Sur, and the Tambara, the Ateneo de Davao University Journal which is probably the only journal that publishes cultural studies on Mindanao. It would be remiss not to mention the Gimba, a quarterly magazine that also publishes cultural articles.
In brief, I wish to emphasize by this brief resume’ that cultural research on Mindanao leaves much to be desired. Below is a partial and preliminary bibliographical listing of cultural works on Mindanao. Since it is an annotated bibliography I think it will be very useful to those attempting to break ground in cultural research in Mindanao.
ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY
BAGOBOS
Benedict, Laura W. “A Study of Bagobo Ceremonial Magic and Myth”. Annals New York Academy. Vol. XIV (May 15, 1916)
The study deals with the mythological concepts of the Bagobos in the first chapter. In the second chapter, it delves into the rituals of human sacrifice, marriage, death and burial. Charms, diseases and healings, taboos, omens and dreams are the foci of the third chapter. The fourth chapter looks into the problems of sources of ceremonials and myths.
The author is of the opinion that throughout the continuous and unbroken communication between the mountain Bagobos and the coast Bagobos with other people together with the intermittent flow of whole families from the hills and mountains to the coast and from the sea back to the upland villages, the bagobos were able to preserve their old traditions and the integrity of the whole tribal religion. She attributed this largely to the presence of the old chieftains and to the existence of trade centers. Nonetheless, she believed that the death of several old datus and the transfer of entire mountain groups to provide native labor for American plantations were factors that brought about marked changes in Bagobo culture.
Cole, Faye Cooper. “The Bagobos of Davao Gulf”. The Philippine Journal of Sciences. Vol. VI (June 1911).
Cole, in great detail, described the various aspects of the Bagobo culture, namely: physical appearance and clothing; religious rites and practices; social structures; legal structure; birth and healing practices; dances and music; and beliefs.
___________. The Wild Tribes of Davao District, Mindanao. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 1913.
This book represents an extensive study of the various tribes in Davao, among which are the Bagobos. It discusses the various aspects of their cultures.
HIGAONON
Baquiran, Lorettra L. “Bukidnon Designs.” Gimba: The Popular Magazine of Mindanao Culture. Vol. 1 (No. 1). Cagayan de Oro City: Mindanao Ethno-Culture Foundation. 1984.
This article os about the contemporary designs utilized by the Higaonon people. These designs are predominantly found in the group’s clothing and accessories.
Cole, Faye Cooper. The Bukidnons of Mindanao ed. by Paul S Martin and Lilian Ross. Chicago: Chicago Natural History Museum. 1956.
This is a study made at the time the Americans were forming the Higaonons into model villages and supplying them with plows and facilities for farming. The newly established villages were replicas of the more advanced settlements of the Christianized Bisayans. The datus or local headmen were being replaced by “elected” village officials.
Francisco, Juan. Notes on Culture Change Among the Higaonon, Vol. 1 (No. 1). 1990.
In explaining culture change among this people, the author touched on their practice of swidden africulture. He identified the months during which active farm work may be observed.
Lynch, Frank. trans. “The Bukidnon of North-Central Mindanao in 1889 (Letter of Fr. Jose Maria Clotet to the Reverend Father Rector of the Ateneo Mnicipal)” in Readings on the History of Northern Mindanao compiled by Renato Reyes y Bautista. Cagayan de Oro City: Xavier University. 1978.
The letter gives the reader a view of the various aspects of the culture of the Higaonon people : clothing and adornment, religious practices, marriage customs, weaponry and other artifacts, agricultural practices, tribal concept of justice and law, tribal etiquette, superstitios beliefs, dwelling places and burial rites.
MAMANUA
Rahmann, Rudolf, S.V.D. “Mamanuas of Northeastern Mindanao”. CMU Journal of Sciences, Education and Humanities, Vol. 1 (No. 2). 1990.
The author devotes a few pages of his work to a description of the crude kind of horticulture practiced by the Mamanuas. The kind of tools used depends on the type of crop. In addition, the Mamanuas gather all kinds of forest products.
MANDAYA
Valderrama, Ursula C. The Colorful Mandaya: Ethnic Tribe of Davao Oriental. Davao City: Tesoro’s Printing Press, 1989.
The book contains a discussion of the subsistence patterns of the Mandaya.
Cole, Faye Cooper. The Wild Tribes of Davao District, Mindanao. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1913.
This is a study of the various tribes in Davao, among which are the Mandayas. In this book the various aspects of the Mandaya culture are discussed.
MANOBOS
Arcilla, Jose S.J., ed./trans./annot. Jesuit Missionary Letters from Mindanao, Vol.1 (The Rio Grande Mission) Quezon City: Philippine Province Archives, 1990.
This book is a compilation of letters written by Jesuit missionaries doing work in Mindanao in the 19th century. Most of these letters treat of the ethnic groups found mostly in the mountains of Mindanao. The letters give the reader glimpses of the culture of the Manobos, among other tribes. Descriptions of their general appearance, clothing, farming practices, economic ventures, as well as dealings with neighboring tribal groups are also found. At the beginning, the Pulangi Basin was settled by the Manobos. The settlements were separated by natural barriers. Access to some of these settlements was made difficult by the hostile activities of the Moros.
Burton, Erlinda. “Gudgud: A Manobo Curing Ritual”.Gimba,Vol. 1 No. 1(November 1984).Cagayan de Oro: Mindanao Ethno-Culture Foundation. 1984.
This article discusses the procedure for carrying out the Gudgud ritual by describing in great detail one such event which the author herself had witnessed. The essence of the ritual lies in the umagad (soul) of a sick person being searched for and finally retrieved by the bybaylan (shaman) from the diwata or diwatas (spiritual beings) who may have snached or captured it to be devoured. The ritual is said to be performed because of the belief that unless the patient’s umagad is recaptured, he will never recover from his illness.
Cole, Faye Cooper. The Wild Tribes of Davao District, Mindanao.Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1913.
The book represents an extensive study of the various tribes in Davao, among them the Manobo. It contains an account of the history of these people.
Manual, Esperidion A. Manuvu Social Organization. Quezon City: The Community Development Research Council. 1973.
In discussing the social organization of the Manuvu, the author mentions in scattered portions of the book aspects of the “slash and burn” method of dry agriculturing engaged in by these people.
Garvan, John. The Manobos of Mindanao. Washington: United States Governmenr Printing Office. 1931.
The book treats of the great religious revival of the period between 1908 and 1910 among the Manobos of Libuganon River. It started with the “miraculous recovery” of a certain Manobo who had already been abandoned by his relatives because of his malignant sickness/disease. He attributed his recovery to the works of beneficient spirits. His people believed that he had been transformed into a deity who has such could impart himself to all whom he designed to honor.
He was later believed to have prophesied the destruction of the world after one moon and that the old tribal dieties would cease to lend assistance to all who garbed themselves in black (non-Christians), with instructions to his relatives as to how they could save themselves.
Dubois, Carl D. “Death and Burial Customs of the Sarangani Manobo”. Kinaadman: A Journal of the Southern Philippines, Vol. XII (No. 1). 1990.
The article deals with the various stages of the rites performed by the Sarangani Manobo for the sick, dying or dead person.
MORO
Gowing, Peter G. Mandate from Moroland.Quezon City. PCAS. 1977.
Gowing described the hostile activities of the Moros directed against the American colonial government in Mindanao in the 1900s and the corresponding reactions of the latter to such activities.
TIRURAY
Arcilla, Jose S.J., ed./trans./annot. Jesuit Missionary Letters from Mindanao, Vol. 1 (The Rio grande Mission) Quezon City: Philippine Province Archives. 1990.
The book is a compilation of letters written by Jesuir missionaries doing work in Mindanao in the 19th century. Most of these letters speak of the ethnic groups found mostly in mountains of Mindanao.
The letters give the reader glimpses of the culture of the Tiruray, among other tribes. Descriptions of their general appearance, clothing, farming practices, economic ventures, as well as dealings with neighboring tribal groups were the topics of many of the letters.
Schlegel, Stuart A. “The Traditional Tiruray Zodiac: The Celestial Calendar of the Philippine Swidden and Foraging People.” Philippine Quarterly of Culture and Society. Vol. 15 (Nos. 1 & 23), 1987.
The articl contains a description of the subsistence economy, of the traditional Tiruray. (The acculturated Tiruray, on the other hand, plow their own, or, more commonly, their landlord’s established fields, repeatedly preparing, planting and harvesting the same plots of land.)
Schlegel, Stuart A. Tiruray Subsistence: From Shifting Cultivation to Plow Agriculture. Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila University Press. 1979.
The book offers a contemporary case study of the transformation of a traditional economic system, as well as a glimpse into the day-to-day activities of the Tiruray, who have been compelled to change over from their traditional subsistence system (i.e. swidden agriculture) to sedentary farming.
Schlegel, Stuart A. Tiruray Justice. California: University of California Press, 1970.
The author liks the Tiruray sense of justice to their subsistence economy which is dependent on swidden agriculture, hunting, fishing and cathering of wild foods.